Showing posts with label From Anatomy Hall. Show all posts
Showing posts with label From Anatomy Hall. Show all posts

Apr 28, 2009

On The Headlines

The Wall Street Journal APRIL 22, 2009, 2:35 P.M. ET

Poems and Tears for 'Silent Mentors' Spark a Surge of Cadavers in Taiwan
Medical Students Bond With Families to Quell Traditional Resistance to Donating Bodies


By IAN JOHNSON

HUALIEN, Taiwan -- A young medical student stood in front of a corpse as sobbing filled the operating room.

The aspiring doctor, Hsu Jun-k'ai, worked up the nerve to glance at the relatives crying next to him. Tears trickled down his own cheeks. But the surgery wasn't a failure. It hadn't even begun.

Mr. Hsu was taking part in an elaborate farewell for eight people who had donated their bodies to Tzu Chi University's medical school for use in a surgery-simulation class. Medical schools around the world have ceremonies to honor donors, but Tzu Chi (pronounced Seh-Gee) is taking the practice to unusual levels.

By the time students here wield their scalpels, they will know the dead intimately, composing poems and slide shows to them, writing their biographies and sometimes lighting incense in their honor. When they are finished, the students will carry the donors' coffins to the crematory, mourning them as their "silent mentors" who taught them with their bodies.

The reason for such care lies in the origins of Mr. Hsu's university. Tzu Chi is the brainchild of one of Asia's most charismatic religious figures, Cheng Yen, a 72-year-old Buddhist nun who in the 1960s founded the Buddhist Compassion Relief Tzu Chi Foundation. Now the Chinese-speaking world's largest nongovernmental charity, it last year channeled more than $300 million in private donations to victims of natural disasters around the world.

Ms. Cheng has broader ambitions. In the 1970s and '80s, Tzu Chi was part of a social and religious awakening in Taiwan that helped undermine the island's dictatorship and helped usher in democracy. The cadaver program is aimed at changing how traditional Chinese society in Taiwan and China views the human body -- and in the process, end a body deficit plaguing Taiwanese medical schools.

Traditionally, Chinese view their bodies as a bequeathal from their ancestors. This means bodies mustn't be damaged before burial. At Tzu Chi, therefore, Ms. Cheng insists that -- unlike in Western medical schools -- cadavers be sutured after being cut up. The laborious process takes days, but in the end the body is whole.

Ms. Cheng also makes a more profound pitch to potential donors: Society needs you.

It is an argument that has deeply touched Taiwanese, whose economic miracle of the past decades has left some morally unmoored. More than 23,500 Taiwanese have willed their bodies to Tzu Chi, allowing the hospital to satisfy its educational needs and supply other schools on the island. Following Tzu Chi's lead, other schools have implemented similar commemorative services, eliminating the shortage of corpses that long hindered the Taiwanese medical establishment.

"The public was conservative about corpse donation, but Tzu Chi has made the public more open-minded," says Lu Ko-shian, director of the National Taiwan University's Graduate Institute of Anatomy and Cell Biology. "Tzu Chi changed that mindset with the power of religion."

At first, medical professionals also viewed the efforts skeptically. Tseng Guo-fang was one of them. Formerly head of anatomy at National Taiwan University's medical school, Mr. Tseng didn't see the point in the elaborate efforts to treat the bodies with so much respect. But after agreeing to teach courses at Tzu Chi, he came to appreciate it and eventually took a senior posting at the school.

At Tzu Chi University in Taiwan, people who donated their bodies to science are honored as medical students' most valuable teachers.

"I was trained as a hard-core scientist and this didn't make sense to me," says Mr. Tseng. " But I began to see that there's more to teaching a student than just technical ability; we need to create compassionate doctors too."

The efforts are spreading to China, where hospitals are also chronically short of corpses. Nine of the students in the February workshop in Hualien were from Shanghai. Western observers have been likewise impressed.

"It's something that we can learn from," said Sylvia Cruess, former director of medical services at McGill University in Montreal, who recently witnessed one of the Tzu Chi ceremonies.

The farewell ritual begins anew each summer before classes begin, when students like Mr. Hsu fan out from Hualien, a small city on the rocky coast of eastern Taiwan, to visit the donors' families.

After a two-hour ride, Mr. Hsu and two classmates arrived at the home of Li Syu Yue-E, a 62-year-old who died of septic shock brought on by diabetes. Ms. Li Syu had asked that her body be donated to Tzu Chi, which froze it for use in a surgery simulation class.

"You want the family to understand what we're doing so they feel part of it," Mr. Hsu said. "We also learned about Teacher Li Syu. We got to know her as a person."

In late February, Mrs. Li Syu's body was unfrozen along with the other seven bodies to be used in a surgery simulation, one of four such workshops the school holds every year.

The night before the workshop was to start, some of the school's 350 medical students gave PowerPoint presentations about the lives of each donor to school staff and family members. When Mr. Hsu's group was up, a classmate showed pictures of Mrs. Li Syu, accompanied by a poem written by the classmates:

Like a warm lantern in our heart,

Like the supple light of the moon,

To embrace you forever

In the fragrance of a flower,

We will remember you forever

Then, Jeff Sun, head of the Tzu Chi hospital's surgery department, addressed the relatives. "The students are right next to you. They know how dear the departed are to you. They will treat them with respect."

The next day at dawn, Mr. Hsu stood, clad in a white uniform and surrounded by classmates, in a small, bright shrine on the university campus. Across the aisle were about 30 family members of eight donors. After a short service of Buddhist prayers, the two sides filed into the operating room. On a screen at the head of each of the eight operating tables was a photo of the deceased.

Slowly, family members broke down. Some prostrated themselves over the bodies, wailing. Others stood silently sobbing. Like many of the other medical students, Mr. Hsu's face began to turn red. He bit his lip as it started to quiver. His eyes welled up with tears. Across the table from him, Ms. Li Syu's daughter, Syu Yue-chen, looked at him appreciatively before everyone trooped out and the service concluded with more prayers. As family members headed home, Mr. Hsu and his classmates went back in to begin their work.

Four days later, the surgery workshop ended, and all reunited for the final funeral. The bodies were taken to a crematorium and the remains put in cut-glass urns donated to Tzu Chi by one of the island's most popular craftsmen, Heinrich Wang.

"This was her will, to let the students learn from her body," said Ms. Syu as she prepared to make her way back home to Hong Kong. "And maybe now I can accept it."
—Ting-I Tsai in Taipei contributed to this article.

Write to Ian Johnson at ian.johnson@wsj.com

Mar 3, 2009

The Final Journey

Our silent mentors were cremated last Saturday, followed by a rather lengthy memorial service attended by the largest crowd ever in school history. Needless to say it was very touching, extremely tear-provoking and poisonously inspiring. The following two video clips (from Da Ai News Television, of course, no one is interested in a humble memorial service that day, everybody is busy reporting the economic crisis and Obama) are just 2-minute illustrations of the entire day, but I think it portrays our spirit of appreciation to our silent mentors nicely enough.

Cremation last rites


Memorial service

Feb 4, 2009

A Letter To My Silent Mentor

Wrote this just after I came back. Found it useful to post it up here as a closing for Anatomy and Dissection. I apologize for the length.

李美順大體老師,

Our destiny was drawn to meet each other even before I decided to attend medical school in Tzu Chi University. It was summer of 2006 when you passed. Initially refused for donation due to systemic edema, you persevered and miraculously hurdled through the limitations before you went off, in surrounding of family and friends. The following fall, I became a freshman at Tzu Chi University.

It would take two years more for our first meeting – two homesick years filled with challenges and overcoming them that gradually pepped us up for a career in medicine. Our first meeting was on 2008, just before Mid-Autumn Festival. Serenity and gratitude enveloped us as we do the final touch-ups of the laboratory. You were lying in a neutral position, fully encased by resin. Your facial features suggest a typical Asian lady – tough, smart and thrifty. Your daughter had earlier hinted at your unusual righteousness, and urged us to learn the good qualities from you.

Over the course of the next 4 months every time we pray I seek upon you to bestow us knowledge more than gross anatomy. Our group was very cooperative and positive throughout. For me it was the opportunity to learn the value of patience, tolerance and communicating with others. I was fortunate in the sense that academia never really burdened me; what I made in brains I lacked in virtues. I believe your sacrifice is sacred in an educational way and somehow you will be able to tell me in times of exasperation and outrage that I must handle this with all the virtues I lack; that life is no more than the good qualities in all individuals – and I think President Obama agrees with us – “with hope and virtue, we can rebuild a nation.”

You are indeed a very special teacher who allowed us unlimited trials over your expired body. In times of wrongdoing, you fidget not nor blame us for the mistake – you took all that to your own and helped us stood up once more. As the semester proceeds into the depths of winter we were constantly challenged by the lack of progress and scheduling problems. You listened to us complaining on the cold of the lab, the softness and fragility of your tissues and even the fungi problem we later had. All this you took to yourself; and as we got more nervous you comforted us with your peaceful smile and lean torso.

You taught us that there is indeed life beyond death. An expired body contributed to the upbringing of 5 medical students to-be. Besides laying the foundation for the ever-demanding medicine, you taught us many virtues and qualities that would forever change our lives – trust, patience and tolerance. You lead us to believe that even in the darkest hour, even when humanity is extinguished by the weakening economy and corrupt world government, there will always be hope. And perseverance will ferry us through. I am humbled by your great gift to us, a present that will forever stay in the hearts of Group 11.

Time really flies – it really seemed like yesterday when we, accompanied by a crowd of seniors, laid hands for the first time on your chest. The first incision was rather swift for me, but for some, it was like a journey to Calvary. To some it was haunting as they have never witness death before. As we accelerate and zip through the semester I grew more familiar with you – your small but strong hands, your perfectly proportioned liver and kidney, your to-the-books spleen and the illness that plague you during the late years of life. You must have had a life of hardships, but yet fruitful and fulfilling to the Asian way.

After every inch of your body had been probed and studied, every scaffold and crease had been identified, we begun suturing and prepare for your final journey. Seeing a complete you laying once more on the platform is a reminder of what we’ve accomplished this semester. Again and again we tell ourselves never to forget the 4 months we spent with our silent mentor – the 4 months of sweat, tears and endless avalanche of knowledge that both humbled us and raised us to the expectations of Hippocrates.

As we bowed to you for the last time on Sunday morning, 18 January 2009, a surge of tears flooded my eyes. I wished you peace in afterlife as you’ve witness our effort this semester. As Prof. Wang announced the official end of this semester, I couldn’t help but recall all the time spent together huddled around the platform – the endless hours working under the lamp and the smell that clung to our clothes fingers long after that. At that enlightening moment, it didn’t matter anymore who accidentally transacted an artery or severed a nerve, all of us understood we have gave our completely and had benefited in our own ways.

Returning home several days after, I feel rather detached from the heat and the familiarity. Perhaps it is the fact that I had somebody who sacrificed for me back there – and comforted me during my most turbulent times – and would do so for the rest of my life.

To my silent mentor, Mdm. Lee, I vow that no matter where I am or what I pursue in future, I would hold on to the qualities that you emanated and emphasized throughout your life – righteousness, patience and tolerance. I would always put my best foot forward in all endeavours and lend a helping hand to those in need. I thank you for your sacrifice and may you rest in peace.

Jan 19, 2009

The Last Stitch, The Last Prayer

The countdown begun since 49 days. Taken during 28 days, day 0 was Friday.

The end starts with suturing our silent mentors, as progress advances gradually more people joined in the spring cleaning team...

Which includes rubbing every surface within the level to something even Queen Elizabeth's palace management team would gasp in amazement.

Every apparatus have to be scrubbed and made brand new. If not Prof. Wang would complain and make you scrub 3 times before being brought back for re-evaluation.

And you think it's just one or two forceps and scaple?

Work typically begins at 6.30am and last till 10.30pm.

At the end of spring cleaning.

Jan 13, 2009

The End Or The Beginning

One week till time to go home. We've practically completed gross anatomy and histology, leaving neurobiology lingering on Friday. What we do full-time now is suturing our silent mentors - every incision and dissection we performed over the skin of our silent mentors will now needed to be sutured and closed - we're rebuilding our silent mentors back.
Suturing can be mundane or meaningful, depending on where your heart lies - basically it's repetitive work, like sewing or knitting a sweater. Most of us can fluidly stitch together the strings while chatting the time away, discussing what to have for lunch and quizzing each other on neuro; on the other hand this is the last and only rite we do to thank our silent mentors for allowing us to probe and pinch every inch of his / her body in the name of medical education.
When I mourn every morning I thank my silent mentor for her unquestioning sacrifice and that I, along with all my lab partners, hope we could learn more than anatomical knowledge. And that we should always remember the basic qualities working in the medical line - to respect life and sacrifice above others.
The day would begin and we'd start suturing - closing every wound from the limbs and slowly progressing up till the trunk. The rule of the game - every group (12 silent mentors) will have to complete suturing and cleaning up the laboratory before being allowed back for winter holidays. As such, as we were inching our way across the skin, some were caught lingering aimlessly, identifying cerebral nuclear areas (for neurobiology), or simply flirting time away. It angered one of my female lab partners, as well as our neighbor group (who sutured with forest-fire speed). It's saddening to see that some take sacrifice for granted when the task at hand (exam scores) are no longer at stake.
Prof. Wang personally toured every group to explain in detail all the cerebral nuclear areas this afternoon. And though many have heard them again and again, they all gathered round with each progressing group. By our group (11 out of 12) the crowd is resembling the population of Lichtenstein. An early group argued that since they did not listen properly (chatting away I suppose) during their round, they wanted front rows during the demo.
I burst into flames in 2 seconds - lambasting them about respecting the 'landlord' and having more common sense - I really doubt I should, but under the aforementioned circumstances I was hardly able to contain myself any longer with selfishness.
I guess sometimes a little cruelty works well for those who see only themselves - my lab partners and the neighboring group had collaborated on not helping those idlers when we're done. The next step is to convince somebody with power to really make up for the difference on progress. I hardly doubt what I am doing is respectable or reasonable on religious or scientific grounds - but this only seems right, at the time being.


Author's note in response to posted comments:
I had indeed misunderstood many earlier groups who had the misfortune of viewing only lesser brains compared to later groups. We all have to recognize that conditions during the demonstration is not conducive per se and frustration can easily build up especially when anger is already present. For this I apologize.
On the issue of suturing I had had no chance of trying on other silent mentors and as such is not in any position to comment on the speed or difficulty of suturing. However, I should say I have the highest respect for all silent mentors and that I suture with nothing but the purest intention. It is to be noted that though the last two groups had somewhat different fixation methods of the cadaver, the 'softness' do not contribute to the effort of closing as during the course of dissection many parts of the 'soft' skin had dried and curled up. The fungi problem both groups encountered later during the course required us to douse our silent mentor with liberal quantities of formalin which contributed to the rapid dehydration and dryness as well.
While the fact that group demographics and talent have to be taken into account, we believe a little planning and efficiency goes a long way in getting the job done - no offense intended.
And last but not least, I agree with the notion that I am indeed exaggerating by seemingly accusing many but the accusative is in fact only a few if not none. For this I apologize as well. Though over the course of the past week I understand that we are not the only one upset about the difference of attitude.
And a final note - I am not changing the above article as a recognition of the mistake I made and the truth contained therein. I apologize again should some find the above offensive and your remarks are always gladly welcomed.

Nov 29, 2008

The Five Types Of People You See In Year 3

  • The 99%-depressive syndrome top-of-class
Zap. Zap - they've done something you need 10 seconds to do in 2. For the entire period of neurobiology, with the teacher jetting at a 10-word per second speed, they almost got everything down - even the lame jokes serving to reinforce your memory to a particularly complex pathway. They won't be satisfied by 99%. It's either 100% or nil. Now go away so that I can finish my 45th review of nervous system!

  • The take-your-own-sweet-time countryside senior
"What's the hurry?" they ask. They don't mind spending an hour waiting for lunch, and they can stand in line for 3 hours for a concert ticket on the eve of exams. "It happens when you're with friends," they commented on your complaints that whenever you hang out with them they always take 45 minutes to decide where to eat and a further 120 minutes to actually arrive there. If this is Year 3, this is no more than a holiday in the countryside for them.
  • The tea-breaker
They get up every 20 minutes. Go for a break every 30 minutes, and sleep every hour while studying. Their notes - as empty as new. Their textbooks could literally be re-sold as new without people realizing it's second-hand. And yet they don't seem to be doing too badly. You sneak into their room and ransack their bags for secret notes - no avail. Only one thing will tell you how they do this - wait till they die and dissect their brains.

  • The pressure-cooked poor child
Under immense pressure, people can do all sort of things just to escape the steam a little. Kick the floorboards a hundred times before you sleep; wear a scarf and simulate the day when you hang yourself; stand on the table while studying; day-dreaming the day you got sworn into the White House...

  • The understanding partner who'd do anything
Those who are lucky to have secured (ok, this word is a little controversial) a partner before this will find an emotionally-stable Mr. Nice Guy useful under many circumstances - buying lunch when exam's due in the afternoon, carrying books back to the dorm in preparation for tomorrow's exam, laundering your lab coat when you're happily partying after the exam, driving you to stock up provisions for the next exams. Anything - as long as it don't involve sitting the exams for you.

Oct 12, 2008

Sacrifice

On better days we would follow the book fairly quickly and have the prize seen before the lab session ends. On not-so-good days we would stumble with every variation - blood vessel, nerve or lymph node - sometimes concealed in fat and connective tissue, and we would be lagging behind.
On this not-so-good day we were scheduled to saw through the backbone. Our aim - to see the spinal cord bedded within it. Tired, agitated and yearning for a recess, I was impatiently and blindly separating the deep back muscles - instead of separating the jumble of fibers into three portions, the mass got divided into two. The softness and tenderness of the muscle mass doesn't help in identifying the three muscles.
Then, of course, came the lambasting. It lasted for approximately 5 minutes, where I just stared blindly on my work of art. Fatigue overpowering me, I did not say anything in my defense but followed everything the teacher said.
At times the small muscles of the body are a mere pea hidden in between the grooves and folds. It takes just two look at it to snap it off. However, losing these muscles would be catastrophic for the living - breathing, rotating the body, lateral rotation (as in the motion of swifting left and right when you shoulder each other and sing "would all acquaintance be forgot...").
The worse came when we were to saw off the backbone. It was a motion requiring force, in other words, a barbaric act. My teammate hammer the chisel through and through while I swing the bones, held together by thick ligaments, until it splits with a crack. The triumphant feeling of moving from step 1 to step 2 is not as overwhelming as seeing the rugged and sawed off backbone strewn at the corner. The sacrifice our silent mentor made was well beyond my initial expectations - they were too great to be credited by words or even prayers alone.
As the lab session progresses I became slowly acquainted with Mdm. Lee. Her conus medullaris ends at vertebral level L2; she had a beautiful palm; her palmaris brevis is just barely visible but it was as tough as a seashell; her lungs - the primary site of her cancer, had been infiltrated with the invasive cells - all the way from the hilum to the inferior lobe, as well as the superficial lymph plexus overlying it (pardon me for the medical terms). It is through her bodily features that we slowly get to know her. Things that distinguish her from others which we would spend time finding out on what caused her exclusivity. Just an interesting note - Mdm. Lee's suprascapular artery runs together with the suprascapular nerve under the superior transverse scapular ligament - the textbook dictates the artery running above the ligament.
It is unimaginable how much others sacrificed for the education of an MD. It isn't the best job in the world but it has to be the most expensive and extensive to train - because it deals with life and death; because these are human beings. The list of thank-yous would stretch on and on, but it must begin with my parents, all the teachers at school, and this very special mentor who contributed more than anatomical knowledge.

And finally, just for the fun of knowing...

Sep 16, 2008

Our Silent Mentor 2


"Even when I'm left with my only bowl of rice, if others need it, I would still give my half to her," such are the golden words of Mdm. Lee, our silent mentor. A typical Taiwanese lady - strong in heart, thrifty and caring, she was the mother to 4 successful children.
After her husband's untimely death, which left her and the family with debts and the mortgage, she learned cooking from her in-laws. Subsequently setting up her own restaurant which would later pay for all of her children's university education. A thrifty person by nature, she would not hesitate to pay up when it comes to her children's education, as she is being deprived of education herself when she was young. This also subsequently fueled her passion for learning - taking up English when her French in-laws came visiting and recipes from the television.
She was diagnosed with metastatic third stage lung cancer at age 60. On the second day she got to know of her illness, she voluntarily shaved off her head - "I wouldn't like the hair falling all over," she said. A traditionalist though, she broke the taboo and decided in donating her body, saying "if you bury me, the rotting would hurt; if you incinerate me, the burning would hurt. I would like the pain to be contributive to some noble cause."
Mdm. Lee passed peacefully on July 1 2006, with company of all her family and friends. She is indeed a kindred spirit whose personality and strength her family members will well remember. For the next 4 months and eternally we would all be grateful for Mdm. Lee's contribution as well as her respected undertakings in life.

We're in Group 11, with Mdm. Lee as our silent mentor

And the picture of a portion of us, before the course officially begins

Sep 12, 2008

Our Silent Mentor 1

I shall talk about the silent mentor (大體老師) in this post.
Medicine is a field of trial and error. Like so many other fields of knowledge, the current understanding of medicine is laid upon thousands of years of drug misuse, failed medication, and dead bodies. Sure, some extraordinary (or naively optimistic) trials got famed, and among these the penicillin won Alexander Fleming a Nobel prize.
The same goes for the field of anatomy. The human body had intrigued ourselves since time memorial, and thanks to curiosity as well as an abundance of cadavers the human body is completely mapped 300 years ago. England by chance a heaven of grave robbers since early times, was the center propelling human anatomy - during its prime students of medicine were known to openly steal cadavers to assist in their studies. Anatomy is not only limited to medicine alone - Leonardo da Vinci and Michaelangelo also grave robbed to study the human structure for art.
Until the 80s cadavers for medicinal education are usually unidentified corpses collected from morgues in the country. Medical students dissect on cadavers without identity, and many have treated them without respect. Education promoting respect and appreciation for them are nonexistent. And after a complete dissection corpses will usually be discarded - nothing from the cadaver remembered except anatomical knowledges for the student.
Tzu Chi University is the first university in Taiwan, and perhaps all of Asia, to promote the Silent Mentor program - where cadavers are donated from the public. One get to sign up voluntarily to become a silent mentor, and after one's death the body will be preserved until it is dissected by students. Among some differences between the silent mentor and the normal cadavers are:
  1. Medical students get to know the deceased through family visits - during the visit students will be introduced to a person who is willing to sacrifice his / her body for laying the basal foundation of a doctor. Besides understanding the reason behind this noble cause, students start to see a cadaver as a 'person' - who prior to death, a significant being with love and feelings - a father, a grandmother, a daughter.
  2. All silent mentors are identifiable and legally obtained - willingly donated.
  3. Silent mentors are respectfully preserved (individually sealed) - some schools simply leave cadavers in a pool of formalin until dissection time.
  4. Upon completion of dissection, the silent mentor will be suturized and respectfully incinerated in a day-long ceremony with prescence of family members and close friends.
  5. Ashes of the cadaver will be kept in a memorium.
The direct result of the silent mentor program is a close and intimate bond between the student and their silent mentor. Students were always awed by the spirit of sacrifice showed by the deceased - in traditional Chinese, or perhaps Asian culture it is only culturally appropriate to die with a complete body. By sacrificing a 'complete' death, our silent mentors brought us into the realm of medicine - allowing us to cut, probe, feel every inch of her body after her death, she intuited in us a strong foundation of medicine as well as the respectful etiquette of seeing a deceased as a being.
Some silent mentors left words before passing, they usually sound:
  • "I would be happy to suffer a hundred mistaken cuts on me than to have the future doctor make a mistaken cut on a living patient."
  • "When you start dissecting my body, its the time I will truly rest in peace for I had fulfiled a noble cause."
  • From a 9-year old mentor "I am too young to contribute to society (she was diagnosed with leukemia at an extremely young age). The only thing I could contribute is my body upon my death."
  • From my mentor "If I am buried, the rotting will hurt; if I am incinerated, the burning would hurt; if I am dissected, it would hurt as well but this is a contributive pain, a necessary sacrifice."
With such noble and willing silent mentors it is no wonder that anatomy and dissection of TCU is held among the highest regard in the school. It is the reason we all look forward to the semester despite the mountains of knowledge and fatigue it comes with.
I would tell more about our silent mentor, a 61-year old lady, Mdm. Lee, in my next post.